Image

Writing Lessons from a Winter Drive

My eyes locked on the dark blue, bright orange letters ahead of me, the FedEx truck hugging the pull-off lane where the snow was thinnest, rumble strips offering extra traction. Me behind it. A long line of cars behind me.

None of us wanted to risk the passing lane. But if that truck slid into the ditch, I'm fairly sure we all would have followed it, single file, like ducklings.

I was driving 240 miles for a routine follow-up appointment. One I'd already rescheduled because of a storm. (Waiting for better weather. In Montana. In winter. Questionable decision.)

That drive taught me more about the question, is my memoir ready? than some of the craft books on my shelf. The short answer: a memoir is ready to write when you have enough emotional distance to see the story, and ready to send out only after it has rested, been revised, and been read by someone who isn't you.

Here's what happened on that freeway, and five things it taught me about when to wait, when to go, and when to keep your hands firmly at ten and two.

What Happened on the Freeway

Halfway there, on the downside of a short hill with no other cars in sight, I was seriously reconsidering my life choices. Then a black pickup on the other side of the freeway spun a full 360.

It slid across the passing lane, tipped into the median, caught its tires, and rolled. Once. Maybe three times. (Or was it two and a half? I still can't decide.) It settled on its side.

I'd never been first on a scene before. First witness to an accident. Need to call it in. I pulled over, hoped I was far enough off the road, and dialed 911.

I narrated to the dispatcher from my rearview mirror. No one is visible from the truck. Someone else has stopped. No, I don't know if anyone's hurt. I stumbled over where we were until I noticed the mile marker sign directly in front of my bumper. Excellent work, Maurene.

I stumbled through my report and was told I didn’t need to stay. I waited anyway. Blaring sirens grew louder. The ambulance arrived first, followed by a fire truck and a patrol car. Semis blazed past, fast enough to rock my SUV and send snow flurries into the air, and I gingerly pulled out onto the road, wondering if I’d be the next one rolling off the road.

On the way home a few hours later, the wind had erased the tire tracks. No sign that anything had happened. I still don't know if the driver was okay. Probably, if they wore a seatbelt. Physically, anyway.

Which, naturally, made me think about writing. (Well. Once I’d gotten home and given my nervous system time to reset.)

Should You Wait for the Perfect Time to Write Your Memoir?

No. The perfect time doesn't come, and waiting for it might make things worse.* If I'd kept my original appointment, I'd have driven on dry pavement. Instead, I waited for better weather and got a freeway made of ice.

Writers do this constantly. We wait for inspiration, a flawless outline, a quiet house, the kids to move out, the dog to stop doing the thing (or things, especially when there are two of them).

Planning helps. A loose outline keeps you from filling pages aimlessly, and I'm all for it. But the outline can be finished later, and the mood may never arrive. Momentum builds momentum.

Takeaway: Pick one small, specific starting point (one scene, one memory, one page) and start this week. You can figure out the rest of the route while you drive.

(*Unless you're still too close to or living it. See below.)

How to Know When You're Too Close to Your Story to Write It

You're too close when you're still living it. Writing a memoir from inside an experience is like driving in a whiteout: you can see a few feet of road and nothing about where it's headed.

The research backs this up. Psychologist James Pennebaker of the University of Texas at Austin has studied expressive writing (writing privately about painful experiences) for decades. As Harvard Health Publishing reported, some studies found that writing right after a traumatic event made people feel worse, so Pennebaker advises waiting at least one or two months first.

That's for private writing. A memoir someone else will read usually needs more room. What happened is the raw material. The memoir is what you make of the events, and you need some distance to do the making.

Takeaway: If you're still in it, write anyway, and call it journaling. Keep every page. Wait to shape those pages into chapters until you can look at the experience and still breathe.

Why You Shouldn't Query Your Memoir After the First Draft

It’s exceedingly rare for a manuscript, memoir, or otherwise, to be ready after one draft. A first draft is like the car buried under the snowplow’s work after a record-breaking blizzard. It needs to sit for a few weeks so you can come back with fresh eyes and actually spot where the story veers off the road in chapter seven.

Revision starts with the big issues: structure, story, character development, setting, etc., and often requires a few revisions. Then line editing, copyediting, and proofreading. In that order.

Proofreading a draft you're about to restructure is like driving through a snow pile and shoveling afterward. (Which still happens. But we try to avoid it.)

The stakes are real. Once an agent passes on a project, you've likely lost your chance with that agent on that book, unless they invite you to revise and resubmit.

Takeaway: Your list of dream agents is finite. Don't spend it on draft one. Let the draft rest, revise the big picture first, and get at least one outside read before you query.

What Writing Habits Keep a Memoir on the Road?

The habits that save you are boring, and you usually build them right after something goes wrong. Lost a key piece of research? Now you have a research folder. Lost a brilliant idea in the shower? Now there's a notepad by the bed, or a note in your phone, or a scrawl on the back of the latest junk mail.

Over time, you'll notice your own patterns: where you get stuck, what you avoid, the chapter you keep promising to "fix later" or the one you keep rewriting. Those patterns are information that shows you how you work, so you can take the actions that help you get unstuck.

Those actions are like the emergency kit in your trunk. A flashlight, a blanket, a granola bar from 2019. You hope you won't need them. You're very glad they're there when you do.

Finding yourself down a research rabbit hole? Look for the one piece you need, bookmark the page, and move on. You can highlight the section in the manuscript and add more later.

Do you keep putting off a scene? Write one small part of it, allowing yourself to start broad and work your way in emotionally. You can layer in the emotions as you go; no need to try and work it all in at once.

Takeaway: Find an area you keep stopping on and make a plan. A short, easy-to-implement plan.

Who Should Read Your Memoir Draft Before You Send It Out?

A handful of trusted readers who know the genre. Feedback is an extra set of eyes on the road, and memoir writers need it more than most. You lived the story, so your memory quietly fills every gap on the page. Your reader doesn't have your memory. (Lucky them, some days.)

That’s great, you may be thinking. But where do I find them?

  • Beta readers: volunteer readers who tell you where they got confused, bored, or hooked.

  • Critique groups: writers trading pages on a regular schedule. I spent about a decade in one, and it taught me as much about giving feedback as getting it.

  • Developmental editors: professionals who read for structure, story, and the big-picture problems before anyone worries about commas.

Choose carefully. Too many opinions can make you stop cold in your fresh-snow tracks. If three readers flag the same chapter, look hard at that chapter. If one reader hates your ending and nobody else does, that's one reader. Let it go and move on. (Sometimes easier said than done. #goals)

Takeaway: Take what works and toss the rest. You keep the final say on your story.

FAQs: Is My Memoir Ready?

Q: How long should I wait before writing about a painful experience? A: There's no universal number. Psychologist James Pennebaker suggests waiting at least one or two months before writing about a traumatic event, even privately. For a memoir other people will read, most writers need longer: enough time to look at the experience with curiosity and perspective, and still breathe.

Q: Will my manuscript be ready to query after the first draft? A: Honestly? No. A query-ready memoir has been set aside for a while, revised for structure and story, read for some outside feedback, and line edited, copyedited, and proofread. Agents rarely look at the same project twice unless they ask for a revision, so the wait pays off.

Q: How many beta readers do I need for a memoir? A: I recommend three, but no more than five. That's enough that, if several readers flag the same issue, it’s something to pay attention to, and few enough that, even if you get conflicting opinions, you can take what works and leave the rest. Choose people who read memoir and will tell you where they got lost.

Q: How can I write emotional scenes if I’m not feeling inspired? A: Writing emotion can be hard, and sometimes it feels forced. But inspiration can’t be counted on, and it often shows up once you start writing. If needed, start by focusing on what happened; the emotion can be layered in during revision.

So, Is Your Memoir Ready?

On the way home that day, I passed two more accidents, both involving vehicles bigger than mine. Neither looked serious. I was lucky, and I knew it.

Writing a memoir asks the same things that the drive asked of me. Start before conditions are perfect. Slow down when you can't see. Let the draft rest. Let someone else watch the road ahead. It will take longer than you want, and it's worth it anyway.

If you have a finished draft and a nagging feeling that something's off, a Manuscript Review is where I read the whole thing and tell you what's working, what needs attention, and why, so you can decide what fits your vision. More info can be found here.

As for me, I made it home in one piece. But now I have to do something about this lingering pain in my wrists from gripping that steering wheel so hard.